A Paradox of Independence and Separation

My youngest sister shared a poignant moment with me yesterday. She was feeling low because she couldn't forget the scene when they said goodbye to her son in Shanghai recently. Her son appeared to be a completely different person from the one she remembered in 2011, when he first left for the U.S.

Back then, he was in his early 20s, looking reluctant and homesick 恋恋不舍 as he departed from his hometown, leaving behind his childhood home and the people he grew up with. Seeing her only child leaving for a distant land, my sister was also filled with reluctance. Yet, she was determined because she wanted him to become independent, firmly believing in the saying 好男儿志在四方 (Hǎo nán'ér zhì zài sì fāng), which means "a good man should aspire to big accomplishments far and wide."

Now, her son is indeed independent with his life in the U.S., leaving his aging parents behind and showing no trace of sentimentality. Ironically, my sister, feeling sad, has taken on deep the homesickness and longing the he once felt.

This situation brings to mind many scenes in nature, where animal parents nudge their offspring toward independence. Yet, as humans, we are bound by profound emotional and spiritual connections. Perhaps unlike animals, we deeply cherish the bonds with our loved ones, yearning for their presence even as we encourage their independence.

This is the unresolved paradox that humans face: on one hand, we want our children to be independent so they can support themselves as adults, on the other hand, parents miss the times when their children were close by.

In the end, perhaps the challenge is to find a balance between fostering independence and maintaining familial ties and meaningful relationships with adult children, which requires understanding, patience, love and a large dose of wisdom. After all, hopefully, we are in many ways different from animals.

views
10 responses
Yanwen Xia upvoted this post.
Thanks to a thoughtful friend, “Thoughtful post. Enjoyed reading it. I believe my parents experienced the same feelings when I left home to start a life in the US. And, to some extent, I feel the same way about my children. Meanwhile, I do realize that separation from your children is inevitable, both physically and in a philosophical sense. Children will grow up and become independent adults whether you like it or not. Besides, because of aging, we as parents cannot accompany our children for ever. It is natural process called individuation. The sooner our children achieve this independence the better. If they were to survive or thrive in society, they must become independent adults who are capable of critical thinking and have clear and mature minds. Having too strong bonds with their parents as adults may not be a good thing. In psychology, it is called a symbiotic relationship, as if the umbilical cord is not severed. It is also called enmeshment in which the borderline between parents and children is blurred. This is not healthy and can hinder children's normal development. I would suggest that humans are similar to animals in the sense of individuation and separation. It is inevitable and a good thing. Having said that, nothing prevents parents from becoming good friends with and mentors for our children. We need to respect the space between us and our children. We need to respect their wishes and goals in life. We can offer advice and assistance only when requested. In the end, there is no need to be sad when growup children leave us to start their life somewhere else. We should celebrate it and encourage them to pursue their dreams and start their own families. That is what humans have done in the entire human history. As seniors, we need to have our own lives, enjoy our retired life, have a few hobbies, do regular exercise, keep fit, so that wre can enjoy hearing good news of our kids' new accomplishments in their lives form time to time. Occasionally, we can meet up with our children and their families and recall good old times. However, do not impose our judgement on them of how to live their lives. Do not make our children try to achieve OUR un-realized dreams. That is life and that is how it should be. I like your posts because they are thought provoking.”
8 visitors upvoted this post.