12/17/2024
In Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance: An Inquiry into Values (1974), Robert M. Pirsig recounts an interesting story about catching monkeys that illustrates a profound truth about human nature and society.
A tribe of Native Americans devised a unique method for catching monkeys. They would drill a small hole in its top, hollow out its inside, and fill it with rice. The coconut was then securely tied to a wooden post with a rope. Attracted by the rice, a monkey would reach its hand into the small hole to grab the grains. However, the hole was too small for the monkey to withdraw its clenched fist.
Refusing to let go of the rice, the monkey remained trapped, oblivious to the fact that something more important than rice was at stake -- its freedom—and even its life. The villagers, exploiting this weakness, could easily capture the monkey and put it in a cage.
The method works because of what Pirsig refers to as "value rigidity." The monkey becomes so fixated on the rice that it cannot see the bigger picture. What it clings to seems so trivial in comparison to what it loses.
As onlookers, we might pity the monkey for its stubbornness and think we are smarter than this, but the truth is, we often fall into similar traps. Our own fixations—on wealth, status, power, or rigid beliefs—can blind us to what truly matters. As Pirsig aptly notes in his book:
"Of the value traps, the most widespread and pernicious is value rigidity. This is an inability to revalue what one sees because of commitment to previous values."
A fitting Chinese saying for this story is "捡了芝麻,丢了西瓜" (Jiǎn le zhī má, diū le xī guā), which translates to: "Picking up sesame seeds while losing the watermelon." This idiom encapsulates the idea of focusing on trivial gains while losing sight of more significant, valuable outcomes.
This saying also resonates with the idea of value rigidity, where an inability to reassess what truly matters leads to misguided choices.
This concept of value rigidity doesn’t just apply to individuals. A country can fall victim to it, particularly when it comes to war. Some countries' obsession with war offers a striking example of value rigidity. Like the monkey clutching the rice, they have become fixated on the outdated dominance, control of resources, and supremacy, refusing to let go of the "rice" in their clenched hands, even when the pursuit leads to staggering costs in human lives, resources, and global instability.
Ultimately, the success of a country—or a person—comes from seeing the large picture and understanding what truly matters and having the flexibility to adapt. On the individual level, the monkey’s freedom is always within its grasp; it just has to loosen its fist.